The Don Corson Dresdener Regulator: On-The-Wrist Review

Apr 10, 2010,13:54 PM
 

The Don Corson Dresdener Regulator is more than a watch.  It's evidence, of a fairly compelling nature, that a man armed with a dream, some ingenuity, commitment, and a large amount of elbow grease can attain just about anything. 


*Author's note: I'm pleased to also present ThomasM's comments about this same timepiece, which he wore for a few weeks, as well.  His thoughts will directly follow my review.

Before we continue our journey of discovery, let us first learn about the man behind the watch, as the two are inextricably intertwined.  In the world of independent watchmaking I think it is more difficult to fully appreciate a timepiece without having some notion of the individual who crafts it, and in my opinion, Don Corson is a most intriguing individual.

Don grew up in the New York City area, and currently resides in Switzerland.  He comes from a family of engineers and musicians, two trades/skills which go together very naturally in my mind, as music in many ways is the lyrical, expressive form of math.  With parents who are both engineers (and musicians), and a maternal grandfather who owned a machine shop specialized in the making of miniature screws for the optics industry, it comes as no surprise to me that Don first chose a profession that allowed him to create something.  This initial professional choice (to be a pipe-organ builder) was what brought Don to Europe, first to Germany where he decided upon a degree in electrical engineering once he realized he was not going to pursue the lengthy 13-year process it would take him to become a master organ-builder, and later to Switzerland where immersion in the traditional home of fine watchmaking set him down the path toward creating his own timepieces in the early 2000s.

It's Don's innate love for, and skill in, both engineering and music (he plays viola) that are the bedrock upon which he's built this watch.  I have not met Don in person, but feel I know him well enough to say the watch is a true extension and expression of the values he appreciates: handcrafting, originality, artistry, and honesty.  While Don is a fellow PuristSPro moderator, I have reviewed this watch without any bias for, or against, it.  Please feel free to provide constructive criticism (or praise), as Don will appreciate your thoughts. 

Dial

The first exposure one generally has to any watch is its dial. This is the "face" every watch presents to the world.  The dial on the Dresdener is no exception, but it's the composition of this intriguing dial that makes it unique.  Don has stated previously that the dial was inspired by a pocketwatch from the early 1800s (c. 1807) made by Johann Heinrich Seyffert in Dresden, Germany.  Like other regulator watches that we commonly see, the Dresdener's hour, minute, and second hands are on separate pinions within different dials.  However, unlike many other regulator watch configurations in which the hours and seconds will be in smaller subdials while a centrally-mounted minute hand sweeps the expanse of the dial, the Dresdener offers a display of slightly overlapping circles of equal circumference -- like a horological Venn diagram of sorts, for those of you who remember your mathematical studies.


The Dresdener presents a distinctive time-display which is both unified and separated.  At the apex of the conjoined circles is a seconds display indicated by a serpentine pointer; at the lower right is the minutes display utilizing a sword hand, and Arabic numerals in increments of ten minutes; at the lower left is an hour display using Roman numerals at the even hours (i.e. 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, and 12 o'clock) coupled with a spade-shaped hand that I like to call "the Corson heart."  The 18K gold hands on this watch are cut by Don and painstakingly polished by hand before being sent out-of-house to be rhodium plated.  Later in this post we'll see that the silvery rhodiated hands are the perfect dial-side pairing to the rhodium-plated wheels and barrel in the movement of the Dresdener.  I find this purposeful visual echo to be one of the many thoughtful little details that infuse the timepiece.



The dials themselves are crafted from natural slate, which in effect makes each watch a piece unique as each selection of slate has natural variances in color, striation, and speckling.  In the watch I reviewed, the deep gray slate was printed with white numerals and indices (Please read Part III of Kong's excellent article about the making of this timepiece to learn more about the transfer printing technique used.  I've included a link to that article at the end of this post.), and was recessed within the ruthenium dial frame in such a way as to highlight the stone's natural texture and sparkle from the embedded pyrite crystals.  Pyrite, sometimes referred to as "fool's gold" is commonly found in seams of natural slate, and adds a beautifully nuanced auric sparkle to the dial of this watch.  Fans of Jaquet Droz's mineral dials or those who are attracted to meteorite dials should check out the slate dials on this timepiece







The ruthenium dial frame's charcoal hue complements the slate dial very nicely.  The dial frame, with its horizontal Geneva stripes and hand polished beveling, adds an almost technical element to the dial, which creates a pleasant push-pull effect stylistically against the organic stone dials.  The dial is cleanly executed with a minimum of writing (For once, someone is showing restraint with text on the dial!), and only the name of the watch's creator, Donald W. Corson, is printed in flowing script in the lower portion of the dial frame.  In general, I very much like the layout and execution of the Dresdener's dial, and I think the design choices that Don has made offer many options for future iterations of the watch.  For me there are two weaknesses to the dial.  The first is solely a personal preference in that I do not care for the use of a serpentine second hand, and would prefer a different style of indicator.  The second issue is one of legibility during certain times of the day.  The most visually dissatisfying moments for me are when the hour and minute hands coincide, most noticeably around 3:45 when the head of the hour hand envelopes the point of the minute hand.  Of course, when choosing a watch solely for the purpose of telling time, any regulator design will present more of a challenge versus the traditional three-hand dial display.  On the balance, I do find the face of the watch attractive, and am particularly drawn to its contrasting textures and complimentary color scheme.


Movement

One thing I love about the Dresdener is the unified decorative theme of the watch, which is evidenced by an examination of the movement.  


When viewing the watch's verso side one notices the ruthenium finish with lovely hand polished beveling, and horizontal Geneva stripes, in contrast to the rhodium-plated wheels and barrel.  We saw this same juxtaposition of silver and dark gray hues in the display of rhodium hands against the gray slate and ruthenium dial frame.  I find the movement to be deeply moving visually. 


The sweeping, curvaceous bridges and their shining anglage practically inspire me to quote sonnets!  The shape of the bridges create a yin yang quality of sorts, as there is a light, feminine quality to some, and a heavier, masculine feel to others. 


I particularly like the shapely balance cock and flowing train bridge.  The polish on the barrel and gears is slick and mirrored.




The movement is of Don's own design, and although most of the wheels are taken from an ETA caliber, he solely finishes and decorates them all by hand, before constructing them into a configuration of his imagining. 


The traditional, time-honored materials Don uses, coupled with his application of the best in modern watchmaking practices, ensures that the Dresdener will be serviceable for many generations to come.  I think this is an important point to note in today's world of watchmaking in which timepieces are now built with increasingly precious, proprietary, and esoteric materials.  I'm not saying that watches made with such materials will necessarily be service-challenged in the future, but I do think owners of this piece can take some comfort in the fact that their watches should be easily serviceable by any competent watch repair technician.


Case, Crown & Buckle

Please note that the case, crown, and buckle on this particular watch are prototypes made of rose gold plated brass.  Don chose to create this prototype case so that those wishing to "test drive" the watch on their wrists could do so without fear of dinging the case, or damaging the piece in any way.  However, once this watch finds an owner the final versions of these components will be produced in solid 18K 5N rose gold.  I found the watch's 39mm case, with its combination of brushed and polished surfaces, to be attractive and ultimately quite comfortable on the wrist.  I'm sure the heft of the final version in solid gold will be even more convincing.  Don's case design feels very handcrafted, and I mean that in the best artistic sense of the word.  This is not a hobby watch.  It's a case that's been nicely finished and bears the stamp of individuality.


The bezel is slightly stepped and flows upward from the rest of the case.  The groove encircling the elevated bezel is polished to a high sheen.  The rear of the case is similarly treated, with the inset sapphire crystal slightly raised above the body of the case.  Again, it's these small details that I find attractive.  The case body is finely brushed, as are the lugs.  The lugs have an intriguing, and unusual shape.  They are relatively slender and long, with a gentle curvature and rounded profile.  The overall presentation of the lugs is one of elegance.





I feel the crown is an aspect of the watch that could be bettered, and Don has already expressed similar thoughts to me.  He thinks the crown could be more "grippy" (i.e. easier to grasp, and wind) to use the word that he and I have been batting about.  As it exists currently, the crown is not unpleasant to manipulate, but there is definitely room for improvement.  Aesthetically, I do enjoy the look and finish of the crown.  The theme of combined brushed and polished surfaces continues on the crown, and care is taken in the execution of both.  The gentle rounded shapes in evidence on the lugs are echoed again on the crown, the design of which feels very elemental.  While I think the crown can be improved, there is already so much to like about it that it's hard to see it as negatively impacting the watch in a significant way.





The watch is delivered with a custom buckle designed by Don to be shipped on a 21/18mm crocodile strap.  The buckle marries rounded and angular shapes, with the unifying themes of brushed and polished surfaces. This last piece of handcrafting winningly ties together all of Don's design motifs perfectly.





Summary

The Donald W. Corson Dresdener Regulator is a timepiece that offers a very satisfying experience upon the wrist.  The watch is comfortable to wear, and it is charming and artisanal in a way that many watches, even those produced by other independent makers, are not.  This is what sets the watch apart and makes it desirable to the enthusiast, in my opinion.  In my experience, there simply is not another modern watch on the market currently that truly looks and feels aesthetically similar to this one.  I found the trefoil dial design refreshing and unique, if not always easily legible.  The movement is very much in the style to which I'm attracted, so I admit to being seduced by that aspect of the watch immediately upon examining it.  The care Don takes with his finishing is apparent.  As Don is a one-man show, he can entertain certain customizations from the buyers of his watches, which is one of the wonderful things about going with an independent watchmaker.  I've little doubt that future Corson timepieces will be as beautifully unique as their owners.

As Don is one of us -- a Purist, we are all in the uncommon position of being able to offer comments, feedback, and questions to a watchmaker with assurance that the words tendered will be read.  It is not often that one gets to ask the watchmaker why they made certain choices and what their motivations were in designing the dial, case, movement, etc. in a specific fashion, so here's your opportunity to do so!  Thanks for reading, and please take a moment to provide your thoughts to Don and the community.


 

To learn a bit more about Don and his watchmaking please reference this interview of Don by our esteemed Chopard moderator, VL Kong by clicking here

Also, herein please find a link to another wonderful series of four posts by Kong detailing the crafting of a Dresdener Regulator watch: click here .

*In the spirit of full disclosure, please note that Don is currently offering a custom Dresdener for sale in the Collectors Market.

Cheers,

Daos

________________________________________________________________________

ThomasM shares his experience with the Dresdener Regulator below.

I had the opportunity to experience the Dresdener Regulator on the wrist for several weeks.  Because I travel to Geneva and the heart of watchmakingland regularly, and meeting with industry executives and various watchmakers of high and low profile, this watch probably was seen and commented by more industry people than most.

I found the watch to be extremely appealing. Not in a typical "wow, that is a fine watch!" hit me over the head with a sledgehammer sort of way, but in a much more low key, "hmmm, I'm liking this more and more the longer I wear it" subtle way.

I started out finding the display hard to read as well, but as I grew accustomed to the display aesthetics, the "analog" nature of the hands - one looks at the relative position of the hands with analog displays, while one reads the characters of a digital display - it actually becomes quite easy to tell the time at a glance.  This is a similar effect with car dashboards - the mind has to process the digital speedometer - what does "35" mean?; versus seeing the analog speedometer needle down low; in the middle; or up high, at a quick glance. Visual acuity is not so critical, it is the "field pattern" that gives you the information you are looking for.

Uncharacteristically for me, I will say that I LOVE, without qualification, the finish of the Geneva stripes on the front, the movement finishing in the back.

This is not "fine finishing" in the Philipe Dufour / Kari Voutilainen school. Interestingly, this was also the point almost universally made by industry people who asked to see the watch - "look at the flaws in the finishing."  What, slightly uneven stripes? Not quite perfectly consistent anglage radius and polishing?

But for me, I love it.

Why? Because it is genuine. It is true to its origins. Knowing Don and his history with making watches, I would have been suspicious if it was finished to Dufour/Voutilainen standards.

And yet, it is far from brutish. There is a refinement that shows potential, yet there are flaws that are not off-putting and make it that much more genuine. Still, it does have that "glow" that I see with Dufour's and Voutilainen's work, not at all common and in fact, very rare...At this stage of Don's work, I would not want it any other way.

And yes, that crown needs more "purchase" or grip. To borrow a term from the knife world, maybe some "jimping?"

If I were in the market to consider a piece from an independent, I would be all over this.

TM

This message has been edited by dxboon on 2010-04-10 13:55:51 This message has been edited by dxboon on 2010-04-10 14:04:40 This message has been edited by dxboon on 2010-04-11 08:52:46 This message has been edited by dxboon on 2010-04-15 20:43:04


More posts: DufourVoutilainen

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

a unique creation by all the means

 
 By: aldossari_faisal : April 10th, 2010-15:04

Yes, its unique quality is what I love about it!

 
 By: dxboon : April 10th, 2010-15:40
There's nothing else out there right now that reminds me of this watch. It really must be seen in person to fully appreciate the work that Don put into it. The pictures don't do the watch justice. Cheers, Daos

A unique timepiece worth an excellent review

 
 By: jfsuperior : April 11th, 2010-07:44
There's nothing that excites me more about the world of watchmaking than when an outside independent talented person arrives to show his own mastery and skills from a clean slate. It is a challenge to the established houses and independent colleagues alik... 

Thanks for your thoughts, Jack!

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-09:39
I completely agree that as watch enthusiasts we are living in an exciting time for the industry. The rise of the independents, the continuing consolidation by the big brands, and the increasing developments in material science all indicate an evolving, dy... 

Truly a watch made for PuristS by a PuristS!

 
 By: patrick_y : April 10th, 2010-22:49
Thank you Daos for the wonderful review! I have been fortunate enough to have the chance to view the Donald Corson timepiece (many thanks to this Gentleman PuristS who so eagerly showed me his D. Corson timepiece on three separate occasions, I remember ea... 

Thanks, Patrick!

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-10:43
First, I must confess that the pictures were largely supplied by Don, and I had some help from others who wished to remain anonymous (probably hoping to help me look like a better photog than I am)! You know my own eye and equipment is not so keen! I, too... 

Hi Quan!

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-09:01
Do you see improvement in the Dresdener as compared to one of Don's earlier designs, or in comparison to earlier versions of this same model? Thanks for reading! Cheers, Daos

Thanks for the review Daos

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : April 11th, 2010-09:08
I enjoyed your commentary very much! Your review is very thorough and your eloquence did a great justice for the watch. Having seen the watch in person I believe maybe 3 times?, from when the movement and dial were caseless in Don's pocket at SIHH 2008 to... 

Thanks, Anthony!

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-11:14
It's pretty inspiring to see what Don's accomplished in such a short period of time. I can't wait to see what's next for him. Thanks for your kind words, and for reading the article! Cheers, Daos

I like the watch a lot

 
 By: Geo : April 11th, 2010-09:38
Love all the details like the special hands and buckle . The dial with the three circles looks very good, really beautiful piece from what I can see here. GEO

Geo...

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-13:17
...I know you appreciate details and craftsmanship, so I do hope you have the opportunity to see this watch in the metal. It has that strange, unknowable essence that all great timepieces exhibit. Have a great week! Cheers, Daos

Thanks for the review Daos.

 
 By: SJX : April 11th, 2010-09:44
I admire the craft and thought put into this and Don's previous watches, even if the styling is not to my taste. I very much look forward to what else Don has in the pipeline. - SJX

The styling...

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-14:50
...is unique, and therefore not for everyone, but there's a lot of warmth and excitement that shines through in this watch. I also look forward to seeing Don's next creation. Cheers, Daos

Fascinating watch; an excellent and balanced review.

 
 By: mkvc : April 11th, 2010-10:18
Having briefly seen (and been much impressed by) the watch, I very much enjoyed your in-depth commentary. As always, you are very insightful, allowing me to notice things I certainly would not have noticed on my own. Did you do any performance testing of ... 

Thanks for the comments!

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-15:26
I did not do any real performance testing on it, as the watch is a prototype, but I didn't notice any real issues with time-telling while I was wearing it. I definitely enjoyed the experience of wearing Don's watch, and if I had the funds I'd definitely b... 

Superb review, Daos, and not less superb watch, Don.

 
 By: amanico : April 11th, 2010-10:47
There is not much to say after all the comments made on this post, but, like Thomas, I love a lot these flaws on the finish of the dial. The watch should have been pretentious, it is not at all, these flaws making it looking...Human. When I saw the pictur... 

Nicolas...

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-18:37
...I felt very inspired wearing Don's watch. While I know I'll never craft a watch myself, just being close to a watch created by a fellow Purist reminded me that we can achieve our dreams through hard work. I'm very impressed with what Don has achieved i... 

Indeed, Daos.

 
 By: amanico : April 11th, 2010-22:12
When it comes from a friend, it is even better! Best, Nicolas

I'm an unintended third party beneficiary when Daos reviews a watch, as

 
 By: CaliforniaJed : April 11th, 2010-10:48
...I always get to see it on her wrist. I must say that Don's watch is impressive. From a design perspective, the dial is not to my taste, but it is really beautifully executed. Don proves with this watch that he is a capable and creative watchmaker. That... 

I feel the same way...

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-18:27
...about Don. I haven't met him in person, but feel I know him more after having experienced his watch. If a watch from an independent maker contains a bit of its creator's soul, then Don's is one I like. Lots of people talk the talk about wanting to buil... 

Thanks for the review of the Corson Dresdener Regulator

 
 By: ED209 : April 11th, 2010-14:44
Great review and nicely written as always Daos. And very impressive work by Don! It's been great reading the past posts about the developments of this project. I've seen and handled the watch a few times and enjoyed the level of detail and craftsmanship t... 

I think...

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-18:18
...Don has just begun his watchmaking journey. In the future, I expect we'll see more unique, beautiful, and increasingly complex watches from him. I love seeing one of our own achieving his dreams, and putting forth something new and interesting into the... 

Great Stuff

 
 By: Meehna : April 11th, 2010-18:31
All before me have expressed insightful commentary on the watch and Don. In an effort not to be redundant, I will only send my heartfelt congratulations to Don and my many thanks to Daos for her eloquent, insightful and thorough reviews. Not only does she... 

Thanks, Meehna!

 
 By: dxboon : April 11th, 2010-19:12
I appreciate your kind words, and I'm glad you enjoyed the article. Don deserves the big kudos here for imagining a cool timepiece and having the gumption to bring it to fruition. Not many can say the same. Thanks for reading! Cheers, Daos

Thank you Daos and Congratulations Don!!

 
 By: sidneyc : April 11th, 2010-23:09
I agree with everybody's opinion here that Don's watch with a little bit of imperfection only shows that it is hand made by a human being. And I'm sure we all admire immensely Don's move from an enthusiast/purist to becoming a watch maker with his own cre... 

Hi Sidney!

 
 By: dxboon : April 13th, 2010-08:27
Thanks for your thoughts! I, too, love how Don has turned his passion from simply collecting to creating watches. It's inspiring! Cheers, Daos

I absolutely love Don's regulators, since I saw the bare movements ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : April 12th, 2010-01:33
... he retrieved from his pocket some years ago. For me, the hands are a decisive design element of a watch. If I am not absolutely convinced by the design and execution of its hands, I would not buy it. Additionally, I consider No. 4 to be Don's finest w... 

So interesting, Marcus.

 
 By: dxboon : April 13th, 2010-08:31
Thanks for your insight about the name of the watch. I wonder if Don will change the model name, or if perhaps the name is Americanized, if you will. I find the movement so compelling. Plus the color scheme of the piece is very much to my taste. Thanks fo... 

Great looking watch

 
 By: AllThingsWatches : April 12th, 2010-20:12
I absolutely love the layout of the dial. The case looks really nice as well, it has a very "masculine/blocky" feel if that makes any sense. The movement layout with the gear train was a great way to re-engineer the ETA components. The color tones of the ... 

The hands can be polarizing certainly...

 
 By: dxboon : April 13th, 2010-00:33
...as they are unique in shape, and have an artisanal look about them. They are not the sharply industrial hands we see on so many watches. I personally like the hour hand best of the three. It's the serpentine shape that disagrees with me aesthetically f... 

squiggly minute hand

 
 By: amerix : April 13th, 2010-10:36
Thanks for your marvelous report, dear Daos! As to the hands, with their attenuated tails, they remind me too much of what has been done to animal and even human anatomy for a dubious purpose. A Dobermann with clipped ears is cosmetic surgery. Serpents an... 

Never a dull moment with you, Amery!

 
 By: dxboon : April 13th, 2010-23:25
Thanks for your thoughts. Don's design has a unique viewpoint, and certainly the hands are not for everyone, but I do love their handcrafted look. As a fan of independent watchmaking, I'm sure you are excited to see another player emerge onto the scene (a... 

Indeed it is!

 
 By: amerix : April 14th, 2010-02:53
and i DO admire Don's work and the sheer effort he puts into it. What a multi-talent ... Amery

What's next?

 
 By: cen@jkt : April 12th, 2010-22:25
Eagerly waiting cen@jkt

How about the words...

 
 By: dxboon : April 12th, 2010-23:52
...half-flying tourbillon? I don't know if this is what's next for Don, but he's most definitely already created the prototype! There are pictures on his website! Cheers, Daos

This review made me smile

 
 By: respo : April 13th, 2010-11:49
I had been interested in learning more about this watch, so the review is an excellent resource for us. Thank you both, Daos and Thomas for the excellent summary and analysis. I am a sucker for regulators. But they are usually very serious affairs, and wh... 

I like the watch's whimsical dial too!

 
 By: dxboon : April 13th, 2010-22:44
Don's choice of hands is not common, and definitely gives the timepiece an air of originality. The watch makes me smile, as well. I hope to see more models from Don in the future. I'd love for him to make a simple three-hand time only piece. Cheers, Daos

Thank you Daos.....

 
 By: MiniCooper : April 14th, 2010-11:49
for a very thorough report..... A very interesting timepiece.... I wonder, how long does it take him to manufacture the movement? Cheers

I'll ask Don...

 
 By: dxboon : April 14th, 2010-21:20
...if he can give us an approximation of how long it takes for him to construct and finish his movement. Thanks for reading the article! Cheers, Daos

Some further comments from Don for you.

 
 By: dxboon : April 15th, 2010-20:59
Don has never really tried to account for the time used in making a watch or a movement, but once the design is finished he thinks the production comes down to something like this. To make one movement: 40hrs Preparation: Production drawings, CNC programm... 

Much appreciated Daos... ::))

 
 By: MiniCooper : April 16th, 2010-05:41

Thank you Doas for filling in the blanks...

 
 By: pingtsai : April 20th, 2010-11:06
So sorry it took me a while to get around to reading your excellent review. I've seen the Dresdener in person and have overheard bits and pieces of its background but thank you for providing the whole picture. It is definitely a treat that we have close a... 

Nice to hear from you, Ping!

 
 By: dxboon : April 20th, 2010-21:12
You've hit the nail on the head with the use of the word "craftsman." Don deserves the moniker. His watch is the culmination of a dream, and seeing that come to pass is indeed priceless. We should all be so fortunate to achieve our own individual goals. C...